Title – The Rule of Jenny Pen (2024)

Director – James Ashcroft (Coming Home in the Dark)

Cast – Geoffrey Rush, John Lithgow, George Henare

Plot – After suffering a severe stroke judge Stefan Mortensen (Rush) is confined to a wheelchair and placed in rest home that has been overtaken by a tyrannical resident Dave Crealy (Lithgow) and his puppet baby Jenny Pen.

“We all get what’s coming in the end”

Review by Eddie on 13/06/2025

A small-scale New Zealand production that managed to secure the not insignificant services of Oscar winning Australian acting icon Geoffrey Rush and screen legend John Lithgow, The Rule of Jenny Pen is a unique psychological horror that benefits greatly from the work of its co-leads but is let down by a wafer thin plot filled with Swiss cheese levels of holes and a sense it never culminates in a fashion befitting of its set-up.

Actor turned director James Ashcroft (who also co-writes here) starts things off in a promising enough way as watch Rush’s long-serving judge Stefan Mortensen suffer a stroke while at work, leading him to a sad and depressive rest home that is being traumatised by John Lithgow’s Dave Crealy and his hand puppet Jenny Pen, creating an eerie sense of dread and intrigue that Rush and Lithgow relish in, only to peter out in an increasingly far-fetched and repetitive fashion.

It’s a premise that on paper may seem like something you’d find in a dark comedy offering or cult British TV show but there’s nothing humorous going on here as Crealy’s increasingly unhinged behaviour and Mortensen’s intense battle to have his actions caught out ensure Jenny Pen is an unnerving experience but also a frequently frustrating one.

Built around a fairly out there premise that’s played with an ever straight bat, there’s an element of suspension of disbelief that needs to be accepted early into Ashcroft’s offering but that’s a requirement that can only take its audience so far as an inept bunch of staff, curiously dismissive character actions and hard to fathom decision making moments take us out of the experience as Jenny Pen struggles to keep its head above a rising water of unbelievable events and reactions.

With the tidal waves of disappointing moments coming thick and fast, there’s no denying that Rush and Lithgow come out unscathed here with both actors delivering top-quality performances and their limited interactions together create some fantastically devious sparring matches, making one wish that the film around them was able to come together in the same fashion as it becomes more and more like a what might have been rather than a what is.

After a period of turbulence in his personal life and a career lull that has kept him to two acting roles in the past 6 years, it’s particularly pleasing to see Rush back plying his trade and while his performance here won’t be regarded up there with the best in amongst some top quality productions, it’s a stern reminder of his talent that we hopefully get to see more of moving forward.

Final Say –

Initially inviting hopes of something great to come, The Rule of Jenny Pen gives way to an abundance of questionable story movements and repetitive happenings, leaving far too much of a weight on the shoulders of its game leading men.

2 incompetent staff members out of 5