Film Review – In the Heart of the Sea (2015)

In the Heart of the Sea - post

Title – In the Heart of the Sea (2015)

Director – Ron Howard (Rush)

Cast – Chris Hemsworth, Benjamin Walker, Tom Holland, Cillian Murphy, Brendan Gleeson, Ben Whishaw, Charlotte Riley

Plot – The “true” story of the real Moby Dick that sees the whaling boat the Essex as captained by George Pollard (Walker) and his more experienced first mate Owen Chase (Hemsworth) take on a great white whale that will test the crew of the Essex’s very will to survive.

“We were headed for the edge of sanity… like we were aberrations, phantoms”

Review by Eddie on 4/12/2015

Let’s deal with the elephant in the room or in this particular case the great white whale in the boat, old ginger top Ron Howard’s impressive looking new high seas adventure is not one of the year’s best (or awards player as many thought) but it’s an often mightily enjoyable time out at the cinema thanks to its visual spectacle.

Delayed from an early year release at years start and set a new opening timeslot in the awards friendly period of December, hype started building for this adaptation of Nathaniel Philbrick’s well-loved novel (or simply the “real Moby Dick” story) that had many calling out the film as both a likely box office hot shot and a real wild card at this year’s awards circuits.

What singular element likely to hold In the Heart of the Sea back from such bounties is hard to pinpoint but a summation could be given to suggest a lack of heart and strangely plotted narrative are key factors to Heart’s inability too truly set sail.

Those who expected Heart to be a real man v whale high stakes thrill ride will be sorely disappointed as that’s really not Howard’s focus here, while others may find themselves growing weary quickly of Heart’s more survival against the odds scenario that sadly features characters we’d love to care a little more about.

From all reports, investing in the characters in Philbrick’s book is not an issue but with Chris Hemsworth’s Owen Chase here leading the charge as second mate of the Essex and its captain George Pollard (played to boorish effect by Benjamin Walker) the crew of this whaling vessel fail to engage us on their high stakes journey and as “big white” makes his debut and the crew start to be whittled down in number, a realisation dawns that Howard and his screenwriter Charles Leavitt haven’t done enough for us to invest our emotions in their increasingly doomed plight against one huge freak of nature.

After so-so turns in Snow White and the Huntsman and the beyond awful Blackhat, questions must now be raised about Hemsworth’s ability to lead a film outside of his Thor comfort zone and whilst his not terrible here he’s certainly not the one to help lead Heart forward to another level and his struggles with nailing accents is again prevalent here, although that’s never stopped fellow Australian ex-pat Russell Crowe. Side players like Cillian Murphy’s Matthew Joy and Brendan Gleeson’s aged Thomas Nickerson end up making more of an impression, but as like most of the ensemble, they are underused and slightly underdeveloped.

This real life Moby Dick is directed with enough assurance and visual flair by the professional and proficient Ron Howard that throughout its two hour run time there’s enough to warrant a cinema screen viewing but you can’t help escape the feeling that in the end we were never hooked the way we should be to this almost unbelievably huge adventure.

In the Heart of the Sea assuredly sails between the waters of greatness and mediocrity to in the end become a sparingly thrilling yet forgettable telling of one unforgettable story.

3 ½ emaciated Thor’s out of 5

24 responses to “Film Review – In the Heart of the Sea (2015)

  1. I absolutely adored Rush, so I was looking forward to another Howard/Hemsworth film, but this one doesn’t look like it hits the same heights.
    So far, I think Hemsworth is best in the roles that allow him charm and humour, rather than just straight-faced drama.

  2. This is really interesting, because I was really looking forward to watching Heart, as I typically love watching adaptations of classic stories, just to see what has changed from one adaptation to another. I felt that when I watched the trailer I thought to myself, Hemsworth is a fascinating choice… because really he looks the handsome rugged part, but I agree in that I do not think his strength lies in straight faced drama. I am still uhming and ahing about whether I should pay a visit to the cinema or wait until the DVD release for this one

  3. Having ploughed my way through Moby Dick relatively recently I am quite keen to check this out. Bit disappointed to hear though that it might be a damp squib.

  4. Pingback: Film Review – Extraction (2020) | Jordan and Eddie (The Movie Guys)·

  5. Pingback: Film Review – Hillbilly Elegy (2020) | Jordan and Eddie (The Movie Guys)·

  6. Pingback: Film Review – Thirteen Lives (2022) | Jordan and Eddie (The Movie Guys)·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s